How to appeal a prior authorization denial

A prior authorization (or “precertification”) denial means the insurer says required pre-approval was not obtained before the service. Crucially, this is usually a procedural denial, not a judgment that you didn’t need the care. If the service met criteria, was urgent, or the gap was administrative, it is frequently reversible.

Decode my prior authorization denial — free →
Typical appeal success when filed properly0%
Directional estimate from public data + Appealify user outcomes. Even lower rates beat the under-1% who never appeal.

What this denial means

A prior authorization (or “precertification”) denial means the insurer says required pre-approval was not obtained before the service. Crucially, this is usually a procedural denial, not a judgment that you didn’t need the care. If the service met criteria, was urgent, or the gap was administrative, it is frequently reversible.

Why it’s worth appealing

Prior-auth denials are highly appealable because the underlying care was often perfectly appropriate — the problem was paperwork and timing. Urgent and emergency care is commonly exempt from prior-authorization rules entirely.

Angle that tends to win

Show the service met the plan’s medical criteria and argue the authorization gap was administrative, or that the care was urgent or emergent and therefore exempt.

What a strong appeal includes

Attach the clinical records that would have supported authorization, any evidence of urgency, and a clear timeline. Request that the insurer grant a retroactive authorization and process the claim.

How long you have

Appeal windows for prior-auth denials are often shorter — sometimes 60 days — so check the notice carefully and move quickly. Missing the deadline is the most common reason a winnable appeal fails — so act early.

See your odds in 30 seconds.

Paste your denial into the free decoder — get the real reason, your deadline, your odds, and a ready-to-send appeal letter.

Decode my denial — free →
Questions

Prior Authorization denials — FAQ

The care already happened — can I still appeal?
Yes. You can request a retroactive (retro) authorization on appeal, especially if the service met criteria or was urgent. Many post-service prior-auth denials are overturned.
What if it was an emergency?
Emergency and urgent care are generally exempt from prior-authorization requirements. Make that argument explicitly and include documentation of the urgency.
Whose fault is a missing prior auth?
Often the provider’s office handles authorization, so the gap may be administrative rather than yours. That argument strengthens your appeal.